"Apache County’s Investment
Portfolio Takes A Hit"
Robert Lucas
The Pioneer
Apache County has invested about $50 million of taxpayer money,
mostly in the bond market. According to law, the stocks and bonds have
to be highly rated and considered safe, so the best return has been the
1.53% seen this past January. Ratings didn’t protect the investment
from losses in March and April, however, as markets started melting
down worldwide.
ST. JOHNS, AZ-The collapse of real estate markets and the consequent
drag on stocks, bonds and securities has taken a toll on the $50 million of
taxpayer money invested by Apache County government.  Portfolio
manager Gary Aday of Morgan Keegan & Co. reported dismal returns on
investment to county supervisors at their July 22 meeting.
   "This is a 50-year event," said Aday, describing the current collapse of
the financial services industry.  The county is heavily invested in Fannie
Mae and Freddie Mac, the largest providers of capital for real estate
development.  And the two government created corporations are now out
of money and on the ropes.  As a result, banks are looking to markets to
recapitalize to replace mortgage markdowns, Aday explained, but are
finding no buyers with money.
   While he was speaking, Aday kept a slide on the screen behind
supervisors showing the boilerplate Morgan Keegan disclaimer.  The
"securities and other investment products" owned by the county are "not
insured by the FDIC, [and are] subject to investment risks, including
possible loss of principal amount invested. . . ." pointed out the disclaimer.
   That hasn't happened yet.  Return on the county's investment fell from
an all-time high of 1.53% in January into negative territory for March and
April and then rebounded weakly for May and June.  The worst showing
was a loss of .36% in April, but Total Return for June was back up to
.2%.  "We have seen negative returns since interest rates went down this
spring," reported Aday.  Still, the higher rate of return in January made
for 1.67% Total Return [Since Inception] "this quarter," said Aday, with
"12% return since 2006."  Actual yield of the portfolio, he reckoned, is
well over 5%, "much better than the two-year Treasury note yield."
   Laws meant to safeguard taxpayer money require county investments
be made in highly rated and safer instruments.  Only 15% of Apache
County's portfolio is invested in corporate stocks or bonds.  One percent
has been kept in cash.  In response to a question from supervisor Jim
Claw about investment in banks, Aday acknowledged that some of the
county's money is in banks, like Wells Fargo for instance.  But it amounts
to only about 5% of the portfolio.
   Eighty-four percent of the portfolio is invested in "agency" offerings
made by other local governments, federal agencies and government
sponsored corporations (GSA's).  The majority of these agencies and
corporations are rated triple-A by Moodys and Standard & Poors,
however these ratings have recently come under suspicion.
   "Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are rated triple-A," Aday told
supervisors, "so almost every public investment has included these
GSA's.  So the feds are going to protect county investments."  Aday also
offered assurances as to the bond and securities markets.  "It's an
important part of our economy and the federal government will not allow it
to fail."
   Of course, the federal government is dependent upon the taxpayers to
ultimately stand behind government bonds and fund bailouts.  
   "I've never seen anything like this," concluded Aday, "and I've been
doing this for 25 years.  I've seen things I never thought would happen."
Very little remained about an hour after a small single-engine
plane crashed August 16 into a pickup truck in a St. Johns
backyard behind the deputy in the foreground. Three occupants
survived, but were airlifted to the hospital with severe burns.
The plane went down about two blocks from the south end of the
runway after stopping to refuel and taking off again. A
firefighter is hosing down the charred wreckage.
A helicopter ambulance revs up at St. Johns airport
to transport the last of three victims severely burned
after their light plane crashed into a St. Johns
neighborhood August 16. The plane went down about
two blocks from the south end of the runway and hit a
pickup parked in the backyard of a home. No one on
the ground was hurt.
Horses in Vernon NOT Being Abused
By Karen Warnick
The Pioneer
Livestock Inspector Kevin McFee talks to owner Keith
Felter during and inspection of the horses and property
conducted on August 15.
Dana Bell and her husband David have long been animal activists and
protectors.  So when they read an article in the White Mountain Independent
about starving horses in Vernon, they decided to go out and see for
themselves.  “We were prepared for the worst and didn’t expect to be well
received.”  But when they arrived at the home of Keith Felter and Tina
Randall, they were surprised to see that the horses were not in such bad
shape.  “They were doing a wonderful job of caring for those horses.”  Dana
and David brought 10 bales of hay to feed the horses but found that they were
already being fed.  The Bells have been out to visit several times and have
become friends with the owners.  “We would have been the first to urge for
prosecution.”  They are doing all they can to support Keith and Tina and the
horses, including educating the misinformed public.
 The Pioneer also went out to see what was going on.  After two and a half
hours spent touring the facility, talking to Keith and Tina and following
Arizona Department of Agriculture Livestock Investigator Kevin McFee
around while he did his inspection, there seems to be much ado about nothing.
 While Keith is the first to admit that having 34 horses together was not a
good idea, it is not illegal and they were only there for a short time.  As of
August 15 there were 16 horses on the property, 8 more on a 5 acre lot in Show
Low Pines, and 9 others were moved to his partner’s 40 acre farm.
 Kevin McFee has been checking on the horses since a neighbor complained on
May 30.  He has been to the property 8 times since then and says, “I’m
comfortable with Keith’s knowledge and everything I’ve suggested has been
followed.  He is very proactive in taking care of any problems and in most cases
I don’t get willing cooperation from owners.”  The horses have been wormed
twice and are being fed according to a proper schedule.  All of the horses are in
good condition and are gaining weight.  “If I thought these horses were being
mishandled, abused or in danger, I would have confiscated them.”  Mr. McFee
also said that the public needs to know that he is out here and is watching over
the horses.  He stressed to this writer that Keith and Tina are genuinely
concerned about their horses and the setup they have for them is more than
adequate.  “They have a large enough area to get some basic exercise.  They
need to eat more than anything else right now.  Exercise runs the risk of
injury, because they are still somewhat wild.”  Mr. McFee also said that horses
don’t get into the condition they were in overnight and it takes several months
to a year to get them in top condition.  
 Keith and Tina are very upset at all the negative attention this has
generated.  They have received several death threats, including one caller who
told them they needed their throats cut.  They turned off the house phone
because of the stress of the calls.  Keith says, “If Jo Baeza had done her job
and come to the house to investigate this properly, and listened to what Kevin
McFee had to say, none of this controversy would have happened and the
article would not have been written the way it was.”  
 Keith said that his first contact with the reporter was a phone message left on
the answering machine that said, “This is Jo Baeza with the WMI and I would
appreciate it if you would give me a call tomorrow. I’m doing a story about
your horses and I want to know why they are in such bad shape.  I want to tell
your side of the story.”  Keith was upset because she wouldn’t come to the
house and didn’t want them to come to her office.  He says, “She spent 15
minutes on the phone with us, never came to see the horses or our setup, but
did talk to all the neighbors for hours.  If she was here to get the photo of the
horse that was in the paper, why wouldn’t she come to see us personally?”
 Keith and Tina have had to put up with all the negativity and someone has
been driving by their house on a regular basis to check up on them.  During a
visit by Kevin McFee, a vet and a sheriff’s deputy, two people were taking
pictures and the vet left, saying he didn’t want any part of it.  The deputy said
it was harassment and they should file charges.  The vet was talked into
coming back when the photographers left.
 It is easy to see how much Keith and Tina love these horses and their goal is
to rehabilitate them and sell them to good homes.  They know that if they didn’
t do this, the horses were destined to be slaughtered and their dream is to save
as many as possible.  They appreciate all the help they have been given and
welcome those with good intentions.  Keith has 5 years experience with horses
and his partner has life long experience in raising and caring for horses.  
 Even though they have been on the property for 3 years and have the right to
have horses, they have decided to move forward in the future with their plans
to build a house on the five acres they own.  They said they don’t need the
grief from the neighbors and the negative publicity.  They have no intentions
of stopping their dream of saving horses.

Northeastern Arizona's Most Read Newspaper
White Mountain Electronics Opens
Doors in Snowflake
Karen Warnick
The Pioneer
Mark and Ruth Anglin stand beside the sign for their new
business in Snowflake, White Mountain Electronics
 There’s a new business in Snowflake that specializes in high-end
electronics repair.  Owned and run by Mark and Ruth Anglin, White
Mountain Electronics provides pick up service and repairs things
like plasma TV’s, satellite receivers, and other expensive
equipment.
 Mark is commuting from his other business in Escondido,
California, one week here and one week there.  His two sons are
running and learning more of the business so they can take over for
their Dad and he can work here full-time. Ruth stays here full-time.
 It’s interesting how they ended up here.  One of their customers in
California had some brochures about Arizona and the White
Mountains and said they had bought some property in Snowflake.  
Mark and Ruth were looking for a place “to put our rocking chairs”
and knew they didn’t want to stay in California.  They started
making trips over here and fell in love with the area.
 Ruth said, “The area is small, quiet, laid-back and friendly.  People
still wave at strangers and help each other.  You can’t find that in
Southern California.”  What’s really funny is that they ended up
buying a home a mile from the customers that told them of the area
and didn’t even realize it.  They have now become good friends.
 In his other business, Mark has worked on such large projects as
hotels, resorts, and school districts.  The turn around time for
repairs is usually one day to a week.
 They are nice, friendly folk who are grateful to have found their
retirement home and that they have already started to build a good
customer base.  Their business is located at 184 S. Main Street.  
The phone number is 536-5400.
We Stand for the Rights of
the People to be Heard
The Pioneer Staff
There’s a verse in the Bible, Ezekiel 33.6 that says: “But if the watchman see the sword come
and blow not the trumpet and the people be not warned, if the sword take any person from among
them…his blood will I require at the watchman’s hands.”
The media’s job is to be the “watchman”, the guardian of truth, the investigator of wrongs,
whether they are committed by individuals, corporations or government.  The media should be the
well-read, the analytical thinkers, the risk-takers, truth-seekers and liberty protectors.  The
purpose of the news in a society is to be a check on the abuses of the powerful and to keep the
public informed with what they need to know to be free and self-governing.  A journalist’s first
obligation is the truth and their first loyalty should be to the citizens.
Unfortunately, those high ideals don’t sell to enough people these days, so instead we have a
mostly bought-off media pandering to scandals, gossip and sensationalism instead of reporting on
the overwhelming issues that effect our way of life, health, safety and future.  Over 99% of all
media today is owned by 5 or 6 corporations that have ties to everything from the oil industry to
the food and drug industries.  Private corporations that decide what the news is with profit as the
main motive.  No longer is the news thought of as the “watchman” of liberty and freedom.  
Instead, the media is considered co-conspirators in pulling the wool over the eyes of the people.  
A prime example of this is the lack of media attention to ALL of the candidates who were running
for President.  What happened to the public’s right to know?  
The Pioneer is a privately owned paper that still believes the people have a right to the truth,
regardless of who pays the bills or who might be upset.  We believe that the citizens need to be
heard, not the politicians, the government, the corporate-controlled business world.  The people
are supposed to be the rulers of this country that was founded on the belief that we be self-
governing.  Unless the people are heard, indeed, unless the people stand up and shout out the
truth, we will become the servants of the elite.  Unless the media return to being the “watchmen”
of the truth and sounding out the warning trumpet, unless the public demands their right to be
informed and their right to be heard, we will become a nation of puppets whose strings are pulled
by our masters.  This great country will be just another failed democracy controlled by dictators
and fascists.  Many believe we are well on the way already.
It is our intent to bring to light that which is hidden from the view of the people.  We believe that
the media should still serve as watchdogs on government, businesses and all leaders and the
people should expect us to bring them the information needed to enable them to make informed
decisions on the issues we face.  It may not be pretty or pleasant and it may fuel controversy and
dissent.  That’s what makes this country great.  To disagree and debate the issues are
fundamental rights that are being denied us in the name of “national security”.
The definition of the word pioneer means: One who ventures into unknown or unclaimed territory
to settle; One who opens up new areas of thought, research, or development; One who goes
before, as into the wilderness, preparing the way for others to follow; as pioneers of civilization;
pioneers of reform.  We are proud to be The Pioneer and we invite you, the people, to join us in
our quest for the truth.
Costs of Wolf Program Don’t Add
Up
By Karen Warnick
The Pioneer
  There has been much discussed lately about the wolf recovery program, not
only in this paper, but across the country.  The question keeps coming up
about how much of the taxpayer’s money is being spent for bringing back the
wolves.  It is not apparent how much is being spent on wolves throughout the
entire country, but the Mexican Wolf Reintroduction Program in Arizona and
New Mexico has a report out that “provides the best-available information on
costs to date of the primary agencies involved.”
 This report, “Estimated Funds Expended by Lead Agencies for Mexican Wolf
Recovery and Reintroduction”, put out by the Adaptive Management
Oversight Committee (AMOC), was recently revised in December of 2007 and
has the estimated costs for 2008 added in.  In the beginning paragraph of this
3 page report it states, “…this is not an exact accounting of actual costs of the
subject activities.  It is simply the best-available estimate.  If a more exact
accounting is required, please contact the specific agency of interest.”  There
are six agencies involved and they are listed as the primary agencies.  There is
no mention of who the secondary agencies are or the costs of these secondary
agencies.  It seems that no one is keeping any exact figures for the entire
program.
 It is also apparent that the figures mentioned in this report are far from
accurate, as the report itself indicates:  “The figures contained herein are
estimated costs, not exact expenditure figures.  Exact figures cannot be
generated because: 1. Cost accounting systems for these agencies are not
sufficient to provide exact figures, especially for pre-1997 years; 2. When cost
accounting system records were known to generate low expenditure reports,
project staff used manual records and personal recollections to provide better
overall estimates and; 3. The reporting periods differ among these agencies
and neither the cost accounting system records nor project staff historical
recollections are sufficient to prevent redundancies among the estimates.  
However, we estimate that actual costs probably do not exceed the estimates
reported herein by more than 10% in any given area…”
 Reading between the lines we can “estimate” that each agency keeps its own
records as best they can, they rely on the memories of individuals, it is not
stated what these costs include, and they “estimate” “redundancies” but do
not include the possibility that they may be underestimating.
 The second paragraph of this report raises serious questions as to whether
the figures are accurate, why the government is not requiring exact
accounting for this program, and makes one wonder why individual citizens
can be held strictly accountable for their money but not the government.  It
states, “The Arizona Game and Fish Department developed this summary in
the early 1990s, in response to its Commission’s questions regarding costs of
Mexican wolf recovery and reintroduction for AGFD and the US Fish and
Wildlife Service.  Over the years, the summary has changed in format and
content, as new information was developed to address new questions.  The
AMOC now maintains the summary and is responsible for its contents.”
 Here is another telling statement:  “In February-March 2003, the summary
was expanded to include cost estimates for all six ‘Lead Agencies’
involved….”  These agencies include:  Arizona Game and Fish State, Arizona
Game and Fish Federal, New Mexico Department of Game and Fish State,
NMDGF Federal, USDA FS, USDA WS, and the US Fish and Wildlife Service.  
That is seven agencies, not six.
 If the summary of the costs started in the early 1990s and the report
estimates costs back to 1977, where did they get the figures for those 15 or 16
years?  The wolves were reintroduced in 1997.  It took years of genetic tests
by various groups of large numbers of people, capturing wolves from Mexico,
and breeding and captivity costs before the wolves were introduced.  The
official “estimate” of the cost of the wolf program from 1977 to 2008 is
$18,091,790 and yet $14,610,911 was spent in less then the seven years from
2000 to the summer of 2008 and didn’t include all six of the “Lead Agencies”
until 2003.
 The chart of expenditures states at the top: “Caution: See page 1 for
information essential to understanding the limitations of the information
provided below.  The costs reported herein are “best possible” estimates, not
exact figures.  The summary begins with 1977 because, to the best of our
knowledge, no records (not even estimates) exist for prior years.  Questions
regarding this summary should be submitted to the Endangered Species
Coordinator, Arizona Game and Fish Department, 2221 W. Greenway Road,
Phoenix, Arizona 85023-4399.”
 The figures on the chart are listed by year for each of the seven agencies
listed with totals per year and the cumulative total, which is expected to be
revised for 2008 later this fall.  According to the wolf program figures there
are only 50 wolves in the program.  The cost per wolf for each of those 50 is
$361,855.80 to date.  If you add in the 10% it brings the cost to around
$400,000 per wolf.  Remember these figures, by their own calculations, are not
exact and don’t list what those costs include.  And this is just for the Blue
Recovery Program.  It boggles the mind how much has been spent in the
entire country.  It is also important to note that these costs do not include
damages or compensation to any individual, rancher or business that has been
harmed by the wolves.  
 It would seem that this program is spending a huge amount of taxpayer
money on a program that is harming many of the taxpayers paying for the
program.  It is currently estimated that the federal deficit is now $500,000 per
person in this country.  The taxpayers pay for the deficit and pay for the wolf
program.  Maybe it’s time that all taxpayers start demanding an accurate
accounting of where their hard-earned money is going.  It’s also time for all
taxpayers to be heard in how that money is being spent.
 The full report can be read at this
link.
Apache County Adopts Smaller $20.7
million Budget For ‘08-09
By Robert Lucas
The Pioneer
Property taxes in Apache County were lowered slightly August 11 by
supervisors at a public hearing in St. Johns, but property tax revenue is still
expected to increase due to increased assessed valuations.  "They have gone
down this year," said Finance Director Ryan N. Patterson as he presented
supervisors with a schedule of tax rates for county funds, school districts and
special tax districts, "right about two cents."
   County supervisors adopted a $64 million 2008-2009 Fiscal Year budget
August 4, down nearly a million dollars from the total budget last fiscal year.  
Then, supervisors set property tax rates to fund the budget at their August 11
meeting.
   If it's not in the budget, then theoretically at least, money can't be spent.  
So every year, the county adopts a budget that includes expected revenue
and grant funding that it is hoped will be awarded.  And at the end of each
fiscal year in June actual expenditures to cover expenses are considerably
less than budgeted.  Patterson showed a total of $41,584,528 spent in Fiscal
Year 2007-2008.
   The county expects to spend less this coming year, because it will receive
less, explains Patterson and Supervisor David A. Brown.  This fiscal year, it
has budgeted about $20.7 million to pay for core county government and
$31.2 million from "Special Revenue Funds" to pay for roads, courts, jails,
the sheriff's office, "community punishment," flood control, libraries, junior
colleges and public health.  Another almost $8 million will be spent on
constructing or buying government buildings, like the four public libraries now
under construction in Alpine, Concho, Eagar and St. Johns.  Nearly $2.8
million will be kept in the bank, while more than $1.3 million will be paid on
debt.  
   To fund these government functions, the county will tax property at a rate
of about $1.91 per $100 of assessed valuation, compared to about $1.95 last
year.  However, most of a homeowner's property tax bill goes to the local
school district where tax rates are set by the board of education.  And,
depending on where property is located, additional secondary property taxes
may be collected for, water, hospital, health care and vocational education tax
districts with their own elected governing boards.  Residents in the Vernon
School District #9 pay the steepest tax to support their elementary school,
$5.20 per $100 of assessed value.  The other school districts collect $4.06 in
Round Valley, $3.91 in Alpine, $3.69 in Window Rock, $3.62 in St. Johns and
$3.28 in Concho.
   The value of taxed property in Apache County went up considerably, from
a total of $352,863,759 last fiscal year to $471,596,971 this year.  Even
though real estate values may be starting to fall here, the county assessor
has raised valuations based on conditions a few years ago.  There is a delay
before increased values show up in a tax bill, explains Patterson.  Taxing that
higher value is expected to produce nearly $10.9 million this year compared
to $8.3 million brought in last year.
   When special tax districts for fire, ambulance, etc. are added to school
districts, the total tax rate is highest in Sanders, followed closely by Vernon,
then Alpine, Nutrioso, Greer, Round Valley, Concho, and St. Johns in that
order.
Kovach Personnel Board Hearing
Recommendation: Cronyism IV
By LeAnn Arganbright
The Pioneer
On August 8, 2008, the Personnel Board Hearing for Akos Kovach was
conducted nearly 8 months after his termination. Sitting through 6 hours of
testimony, the five-person board went home with a lot of information and yet
many feel that only part of the story was told. After the hearing, each of the
board members were allowed to give their own observations and
recommendations in writing. 4-1 they decided that Akos’ firing was
“justified.”
The two attorneys summed up their positions at the end, in their concluding
arguments. James Penny, an attorney from Tucson gave his summation,
saying that Akos’ was not openly defying a legal order from a supervisor.
Instead, he was fulfilling a promise to a client who asked Kovach to not
make copies and not let the documents leave his possession. Kovach had the
settlement documents only for the use of correcting an article, which
appeared in the Holbrook Tribune, late 2007. After everyone who wanted to
see the documents had the chance, Kovach destroyed them.
The primary debate was established early through the testimonies given
which included the city’s contracted attorney, Sterling Solomon, the
Personnel Director Vicky James, City Clerk Cher Milage and the Interim
City Manager Fern Larson. The question of whether the docs at issue were,
in fact, public documents of the City of Holbrook, or where they personal
possessions held, in trust, by Akos Kovach. Both sides agreed that there was
plenty of reason to argue both sides, and that more typically, the issue
should have been debated in a court rather than a personnel hearing. It also
became obvious in that discussion that the documents in question were not
even court documents. They were settlement documents that were the
property of Mr. Tom Nevis and the other parties involved in the settlement
alone.
Penny took some time to explain what the law said as it described what a
“public record” is and what the law says about forcing an employee to do
something they feel is against the law. “The law states very clearly, that it is
not what the boss says, the manager, or the town attorney believes is against
the law, it is what the employee believes is against the law. Akos believed
that he was being forced to do something he strongly believed was wrong,”
said Penny.
Mr. Penny argued that these documents were not the property of the town
because they were not public documents of any type and Mr. Nevis had the
right to dictate what happens to his personal financial records, just as no
government agency can compel someone to produce IRS tax documents as
public records.
Try as he might, Mr. Penny could not convince the board that Akos Kovach
had been fired without just cause.
Holbrook’s’ representation, Mr. Justin Pierce, explained the towns’ position
was one of willful disregard of a direct order. Solomon, Larson and James all
testified to their frustration that they could not convince Kovach to ask Mr.
Nevis for another set of documents. Under the pressure of threats to sue the
City of Holbrook by Jim Gray—the father of the author of the misleading
article in the Tribune, Tammy Gray-Searls—Solomon gave legal advice to
the city which changed the status of the papers from “private” to “public.”
Solomon decided that since Kovach had shown the documents to several
businessmen in town; The Tribune’s owner Paul Barger; some of the
Councilmen in the confines of the Town Hall and in the process of doing his
job that the documents were now the public property of Holbrook.
Pierce said that the tactic Penny was using is an old law school trick. “If the
facts don’t weigh in on your side, use the law.” He instructed the Board to
pay no attention to what Penny said because this case was about whether or
not Kovach was rightfully fired.
The subject of whether the demand for the documents was reasonable, only
briefly turned to the timeline of when Jim Gray’s request came in, after or
before it was known that the papers were shredded—and not fully
established. Kovach testified that Jim Gray was given an opportunity to see
the papers (declined by Gray) when they were displayed at an HIDC
meeting, shortly after the Kovach received them.
After numerous requests and pressure from Gray and others, Larson
decided to give Kovach official written warning to demand that Kovach have
Nevis produce the papers, which Kovach declined, saying that someone else
in the town should do it. He would not participate in violating Nevis’ privacy.
Larson refused to reassign the request to another staff member and
processed termination orders after a short hearing. “He defied a direct
order! You can’t put up with that! This person is not worth your
consideration!” exclaimed Mr. Pierce as he argued Holbrook’s position.
The Personnel Board was given until Wednesday, August 13, to deliver their
recommendations. With those turned in, a special council meeting was
scheduled to allow the council to make a final determination after reading the
panels decisions. However, the discussion was delayed because of a problem
of proper notification to Mr. Kovach and his attorney. This would make four
such delays involving this one hearing, stemming from the city clerks
mistakes or failure to follow proper notification procedures. Those in
attendance of the meeting on August 15, were notified that a new meeting
was scheduled for 4 p.m. Monday, August 18th, but by the end of Friday, at 5
p.m. the letter to Kovach was still not in his possession. Again, the proper
notification procedure was not followed—for the fifth time—when the
envelope was presented to the Kovach home in his absence, with less than
the prescribed 24-hour business day notification, and without the acceptance
signature from Mr. Kovach. Neither meeting on August 15th, and the 18th
are posted on the city’s web site as required by law as of Sunday the 16th.
Kovach says that he believes that the town should follow its own procedures
for a change and will ask to delay the meeting until they have notified him
properly. He hopes that the town will schedule a new meeting when his
attorney has returned from his trip to China later next week.
Others who were witness to the hearing said that they felt that some of the
people who testified for the town may have perjured themselves as they were
repeatedly asked if they had hard feelings, or hated Mr. Kovach. Both
Kovach and David Newlin wrote in their complaints that the atmosphere at
the town hall was “extremely toxic” and highly charged. Those complaints
were written well before David Newlin was forced to resign and Akos
Kovach was fired.
Gary Vasko’s Story Illustrates
Sheriff Dept. Abuses
By Leann Arganbright
The Pioneer
Introduction: This story has three possible versions. We will try
to tell all of them. Gary Vasko’s experiences with MCAT, (Major
Crimes Apprehension Team) the Sheriff’s Department and the
Navajo County Jail illustrates how good intentions lead to tragic
outcomes and potential misuse of power. Gary Vaskos story will
be told through another couple who lived with Mr. Vasko briefly
and were arrested with him. Their side is vital to the story, to be
told in part two. The Sheriff’s Department has been invited to tell
their side in the third chapter. This story contains revelations that
will be upsetting to many people. Please remember, there are
THREE sides, to be told one at a time.
      Gary Vasko sat at his small breakfast table early in the morning on May
22nd, to enjoy the simple pleasure of a cup of coffee to start his day.
Contemplating his future was a full time adventure lately. He had a new start
in so many ways. The old ways were full of drama from a variety of sources.
Being in trouble before, he spent over 20 years in prison for things he did
when alcohol and drugs controlled his life.
      When he came home, he found his mother not only welcomed him, she
needed him. She was dying, and so for the next three and a half years the
two of them went through the indignity of her suffering, and his redemption
and remediation. Almost three years after her death, Gary still lives in that
house.
      No job was available for a man like Gary in Heber, he wasn’t young,
strong, or gifted, but he could cook, and so, an offer was made to the
Catholic Church who agreed to rent an unused vending trailer, and they
came up with a way to solve the problem of needing a source of money for
him.
      “Smoked, by Gary” was created through a loose partnership of the
trailer, owned by the local Catholic Church, and a significant cash investment
(paid for and built by Vasko) to improve the trailer, and get it ready for
barbeque catering with all the necessary licenses. Lining up his summer
agenda was his focus. It was barbeque season and he had the next few
months to make his money for the rest of the year.
      The trailer was next to the garage full of food for the next catering job
he had lined up. He had a couple of housemates that shared some of his
costs for a little while. They were moving out to live near relatives in the
Vernon area. They had some problems.
      Still dressed in only typical night-clothes; underwear, his robe, and some
socks, at about 6 a.m., Vasko was startled from his chair as his unlocked
door was busted open shattering the doorframe. Police announced that he
was to put his hands up and as he did, he looked down to find that there were
five, maybe six red dots of light on his shirt. He didn’t move.
      Through the controlled chaos of being hand-cuffed, his dogs being
rounded up, and his upstairs residents being rousted, Vasko asked for the
warrant from the Sheriff’s deputies, MCAT officers said they didn’t have
one.
      Vasko was arrested for “possession” and placed in the back seat of the
car while the Sheriff’s deputies ripped through his house, searching for what
he did not know. He was told that his house was a meth lab, and his house—
his mother’s house really, was being declared a biochemical hazard and
quarantined.
      By the end of the day, the house, once tidy and neat, was a disaster.
Every book was off the shelves, every article of clothing on the floor in a
heap. Everywhere one looked, in every room, it was a mess.
      No drugs were found. The entire house was cleared by a haz-mat team,
but the sign was placed on the fence, declaring to the world that this house,
on this quiet street in Heber was a meth house and was quarantined. No one
was allowed to enter because of the hazard from the contamination of
cooking meth on the property. It didn’t take long for the word to get out and
his neighbors, it would be safe to say, were not happy.
      After sitting in the police car for several hours while they searched,
Vasko and renters, Tom and Michaela, were taken to the County Jail to be
booked and interrogated. Tom and Michaela are disabled and were on heavy
medications prescribed by their doctor. The injuries were so bad that they
could not be operated on without additional risk to their lives, so they were
forced to use lots of big injections to cope.
      After they got to the jail Tom, clearly a frail man, began go show serious
distress. After Vasko yelled and screamed, explaining that they were
severely disabled, needed very strong medications and that he was obviously
dying, help was called. An ambulance came and Tom was taken to the
hospital where Vasko believed he stayed for the next ten weeks. It was
explained to Vasko that at some point of Tom’s arrest, Tom was body-
slammed to the ground and possibly hit his head on something. The hospital
staff had a hard time stabilizing Tom and could not allow him to go home until
he was able to care for himself.
      Vasko explained what was told to him; Tom’s wife, Michaela was not
allowed to retrieve her prescribed medication and was told that if she
confessed to a lesser charge and accepted probation, she would be allowed to
go home and get her meds. After she did this, it was explained to her that she
also would need to press charges against a friend who was storing a valuable
collector’s car for them while Tom worked on restoring it. She was told what
to say and to write down every word, a complaint that he did not have
permission to be in possession of the vehicle and that it was stolen. The man
was arrested and the car was confiscated by the Sheriff’s Department
(MCAT).
      Days later at her hearing, Michaela tried to rescind her confession and
charges against her friend, but the judge would not let her explain why and
denied her request.
      Vasko stayed in the county jail for almost 15 full days before he was
able to see a judge and ask for an attorney. He was sent home on June 3,
where he was walked outside the jail at about 3 p.m. with nothing on but the
robe and socks he was arrested in. Vasko was informed that he was welcome
to use the public pay phone outside to call someone for a ride. The heavy
metal door shut and of course, the phone didn’t work.
      So he set out on the 41-mile hike back home to Heber from Holbrook.
He had walked 3 or 4 miles when a young couple was kind enough to double
back to pick him up. His feet were a wreck by then. By the time he reached
the home of Bob and Patty Schuttenhelm, clients and friends, his feet were
so bloody that it was an unpleasant process to get his socks off and his feet
cleaned up.
      Still, he was worried about his BBQing trailer and walked three blocks to
his house to check on it where he left plugged in, and full of frozen meat and
canned food. It wasn’t there anymore.
      He went to Our Lady of Assumption Catholic Church and found The
Men’s Club meeting underway. Most of them left after he appeared at the
door. He was met at the door by Father Chacon and Don King, where he was
told that Sergeant KC Clark with the MCAT division of the Sheriff’s
Department had told them to take the trailer off the property and destroy the
food that was in it. When they took the trailer and the food, they felt that the
frozen food was not bad and so it was distributed to the Catholic Men’s Club.
(This explanation has since morphed to a variety of versions, which include
that the food was all bad because it had been left unplugged for a while, or
that they threw all the food away that day, or that MCAT’s KC Clark took
it.  To confuse things more, at least one of the meat recipients has offered to
compensate Vasko for his share. Vasko was promised $400 but was only
paid $200 from one man. $300 dollars of cooked pork butt was supposedly
fed to someone’s dogs after being found in a dumpster. Vasko paid the
church $40 a month for renting the trailer and he was paid up through the end
of June.)
      By the time Vasko got permission to enter his house from his attorney,
he found that his clothes had been defecated on by humans, (there were 2
cats left in the home, and cats can’t defecate on the side of a bed) and the
two cats had been allowed to take over the house for more than 15 days with
only a torn open bag of dog food to survive on. (Someone had gone in, and
set the dog food high in a rafter for the cats to get to; presumably someone
in the Sheriff’s dept since there was still a sign on the property that it was a
hazardous meth lab quarantine.) His four dogs had been sent to the Humane
Society and the Schuttenhelms were able to rescue only the puppy, a Lhaso
Apso, from death. Vasco couldn’t afford the charges to get his other dogs out
of the pound, so they were euthenized.
      Vasko’s court appointed attorney had explained to him that he was able
to be in the house because it had been declared—in the paper work—that
there was no contamination of hazardous chemicals, so he could take the sign
down and occupy the house.
      He did what was advised to him by his court appointed attorney, and
went back to his home, when Deputy Davis drove by to check on the house,
he became “completely unglued” and yelled at Vasko with lots of vulgar
language, that he was not to occupy the house or take the sign down, Davis
put up a new one, which remains today. Vasko asked Davis why he was able
to occupy the house for only few hours if it was cleared, why the church was
allowed to retrieve the trailer if it was contaminated, why someone had gone
in his house to put up dog food for his cats, and why was Davis going in it, if
it was, in fact, quarantined? Deputy Davis had no answers, he left saying
that he would call his supervisor and didn’t return.
      Even though there were no drugs at the house, nor was there any meth
contamination, bottles of common household items, such as pain thinner and
engine oil and fuel were bottled up and sent to the lab. They all came back as
the items they were marked as.
      Possibly, because of Michaela’s confession, charges remain on all three,
and the house remains under quarantine. Gary Vasko has no income, no food
for his catering business, he was not on the title of the house because the
house was still in his mother and brother’s name and had not been switched
yet. Twelve weeks have gone by, Vaskos bills are piling up, his friends are
trying to help the best they can, but this kind of problem seems to be very
expensive and currently has no end in sight.
      The year looks pretty bleak and Mr. Vasko is wondering how he will get
through the next year with his business in the tank from the accusations, the
destruction of his reputation, and once profitable business.
      When asked why Vasko thought this was happening to him he explained
that MCAT was losing their funding in this years’ budget battle. He believes
they were on their own to fund their department and were looking for easy
marks with property to seize. He was an easy mark because he had been in
trouble before, served time, had roommates that were up to their necks,
literally, in their prescribed medications and could have been cooking meth
somewhere else to pay for the drugs they needed. They were already in the
process of moving out but he still had no idea of what it takes to cook meth,
because it never happened at his house, as the tests concluded.
      Vasko has had a second hearing where Mr. Woods (his court appointed
attorney) explained that the issue could not be heard because the Sheriff’s
Department had not released the information on the bust and arrest he had
requested. They were given another week by the judge.
      The Catholic Church and Mr. Vasko have not been able to reach an
agreement on how, or if the Men’s Club will compensate him for the food
they took. (Valued at over $2100) Vasko believes that their actions seem to
indicate that his potential guilt of the charges have something to do with their
unwillingness to help Mr. Vasko regain his property. The Church has been
instructed to give the trailer back to Mr. Vasko, since they have a policy to
not rent their equipment out and because of Mr. Vasko’s personal
investment into the trailer. Vasko has, so far been unwilling to accept the
trailer. He feels that it would be given to him in exchange for the food that
was taken, and he would rather have the food, a far more valuable asset in
his mind.
      After interviewing Mr. Vasko, we are not really sure if he knows what
meth is, other than an illegal drug.
      A recording of the interview with Mr. Vasko is available to anyone who
wants one at the requester’s expense. Current Mac computer systems only
can play this recording.
Want to tell us
Your Side of the Story?

Click Here.

You must include your name
and telephone number so that
we can contact you for an
interview. Anything submitted
without contact information
will be ignored. Your
Information will be held in the
strictest confidence.